How to reckon with Aaron Sorkin’s Facebook follow-up The Social Reckoning
The film itself is like a social media feed: a shout into the void that throws out a bunch of news links and clever references, none of it terribly new or interesting. But hey, at least it’s fact-checked.
Abby Olcese:
The Social Reckoning opens with a white woman (Portia Doubleday) being approached on the side of a highway by a pair of cops. The cops (Nathan Witte and Crystal Balint) are Black. What starts as a routine interaction (she’s waiting for AAA to tow her overheating car; the officers stop to make sure she’s okay) escalates when the cops realize the woman is drunk. The woman goes from defensive to belligerent. She starts shouting slurs. Then, she turns on her phone and goes live on Facebook. We later learn this unnamed character wasn’t always this way. She volunteered for progressive causes.
She was nice. What happened?
Aaron Sorkin’s spiritual sequel to 2010’s The Social Network tackles the Wall Street Journal’s reporting on Facebook’s poor regulation that led to dangerous political radicalization, including the January 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol. The same reporting also led to the recent massive addiction and mental health lawsuit against Facebook, resulting in a $17.1 billion settlement.
The Social Reckoning is part journalism thriller, part war room drama, switching between its two main plots.
In one, Journal reporter Jeff Horwitz (Jeremy Allen White) works with Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen (Mikey Madison) to uncover proof that Facebook’s “meaningful social interaction”-based algorithm led users toward extremist political groups. In the other, Facebook founder/CEO Mark Zuckerberg (Jeremy Strong) prepares for a congressional hearing on online free speech regulation that’s interrupted by the January 6 attacks.
Sorkin is concerned about the right things: online radicalization and degrading mental health through social media use. He is, unfortunately, concerned about those issues in a very Aaron Sorkin way, which is to say preachy and generally annoyed that people don’t care about old movies and classical literature enough.
This is a movie where you know who the good guys are because they know the difference between “conscious” and “conscientious,” can reference Antigone and know what the Pentagon Papers are, despite being millennials or younger. If you happen to know a gainfully employed straight guy in his late 30s who loves both basketball and the 1951 movie Show Boat, please let him know that he is an absolute unicorn, and that I am available.
The Zuckerberg-focused portion of the film fares scarcely better, with Strong’s CEO yelling at folks like Bill Burr’s Charlie—an ex-Facebook investor with Big Concerns over its fact-checking practices—for suggesting he should either end political ads on the platform or invest in ensuring their accuracy. Burr is our voice of reason, jumping in on Zuckerberg’s congressional practice run to ask why he lets alt-right groups and conspiracy theorists post with abandon.
Sorkin is, once again, preaching to a choir largely made up of people for whom none of this information will be surprising.
Part of what made The Social Network an instant classic was its character work, taking what was part of the record at that time and speculating on what kind of person would do or say those things. By now, we know exactly what kind of person Mark Zuckerberg is, and what drives his choices as a corporate leader with outsized wealth and influence. It’s the same thing that drives everyone else: Money.
The Social Reckoning also oversimplifies the main problem: You don’t go from progressive cause volunteer to alt-right banshee because an algorithm led you down a primrose path. You get there through poor critical thinking skills. In one moment, Burr’s Charlie tells Zuckerberg he needs to realize how gullible people actually are, but it barely registers. The almighty algorithm here, as it so often is, gets illustrated as an instant poison rather than the reality: a system designed to reinforce what it thinks you want to see.
So, does The Social Reckoning work as a movie? Kinda.
White and Madison have a Capra-esque chemistry, and the journalism scenes have a righteous momentum that’s fun to watch (it helps that a playful Alexandre Desplat score undergirds it). Burr’s retorts to Strong seem preachy, but they do clarify information to make sure even the folks at the back of the room are getting it.
Like so many recent Sorkin projects, however, The Social Reckoning is weak sauce that’s unnecessarily proud of itself for doing the bare minimum. Oddly, it’s not unlike a social media feed: a shout into the void that throws out a bunch of news links and clever references, none of it terribly new or interesting. But hey, at least it’s fact-checked.
Brock Wilbur:
One of the film’s main characters acknowledges the central thesis as “Everyone knows what happens on Facebook, but no one knows what happens inside Facebook.” The idea that Facebook users are not to blame because they do not understand Facebook’s form and functionality has long served as a launchpad for arguing that the social media behemoth requires government oversight. Seemingly the natural solution, for both the characters within the film and the filmmakers, is to explain how Facebook works. This is a logical approach, but unfortunately one woefully disconnected from reality. You can explain to an addict how heroin works, but that has never stopped anyone from continuing to use heroin.
The Social Reckoning is peak Aaron Sorkin, for better and worse. No fair comparison can be made between this and The Social Network—where director David Fincher, beautiful cinematography, an all-star cast, and a Reznor/Ross score made one of the best tell-alls of the new century. Sorkin, as both writer and director, makes do with what he has, and the result is far from lackluster cinema. Somewhere between A Few Good Men and Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, there’s an undeniable charm here, a couple of hypnotic performances, and Sorkin’s trademark high-speed monologues full of sick burns.
But what is the purpose of making this movie?
Taken as a whole, The Social Network is the story of a series of characters whose insecurities drove the meteoric rise of a business that would poison every connection that made them human. The Social Reckoning is, taken as a whole, an explainer for algorithms that have fueled hate speech, divisiveness, misinformation, and societal collapse. Even though the film features real people’s stories on the big screen, each character serves only as a delivery method for more data, statistics, and resentment. These things are incredibly important. But throughout, I couldn’t shake that Reckoning would’ve been a better film—and a more effective weapon against the continued harm of Facebook—if it weren’t simply a documentary.
The truth of it is… if you’ve stopped using Facebook, then congrats. I mean, you’re still probably using some product in the Meta family like Instagram, but if you broke free, again, congrats. If you or a family member still uses Facebook, you should know how it twists your worldview… but you probably already knew that, to some greater or lesser degree. I don’t think I can invent a person who thinks their Facebook feed represents how ALL people from ALL walks of life currently feel, and some cynicism is probably inherent. To know the true scope and scale is horrifying. The reason people like Mark Zuckerberg would choose to do this to you (and us) isn’t really explained. Sure, money or power, but does he ever have enough? I mean, doesn’t he? The movie never really explains why, so we’re left with some bad people who are bad for the sake of making an imaginary line go up, and two cookie-cutter protagonists who stand against them.
Again, a perfectly fine movie with good intentions, but Sorkin’s lack of directing/filmmaking talent combined with tonal whiplash and murky delivery winds up rendering The Social Reckoning far less West Wing and far more (derogatory) The Newsroom. Congratulations, Captain Hindsight, this was all very bad. The people behind it will never be held accountable for their actions, so what do you want me to do with that?


