Sunrise on the Reaping offers up something new to The Hunger Games without sacrificing soul
The “enshittification” of beloved, original stories has fatigued me beyond belief—just look to the dozens of reboots and extraneous entries in the worlds of Marvel, DC, and Harry Potter this year. So, when I initially heard Suzanne Collins was writing more for The Hunger Games, I was apprehensive. I cannot stomach much more nostalgia-baiting fan service with no substance to justify its existence.
However, she has proven that you can add to a story in a way that enriches it. She doesn’t neatly tie up every loose end, but she added important context that accounted for and clarified certain characters and plot lines.
The first revisit to Panem and The Capitol gave us President Snow’s origin story, and I thought it made his relationship with Katniss and District 12 much more interesting. The book/movie The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, in my opinion, wasn’t on par with the original trilogy, though. Despite Rachel Zegler’s amazing voice and performance, it didn’t send that same edge-of-your-seat feel.
Sunrise on the Reaping shoves you right there.
This story follows Haymitch Abernathy, the sole surviving victor of The Games in District 12 during Katniss and Peeta’s turn in the televised death match. The grouchy recluse was forced to lead two children to their deaths in the arena for 24 years after his games, and he, understandably, took to the bottle frequently to cope.
He seemed to have lost all hope for the rebellion against the tyrannical Capitol and President Snow until Katniss and Peeta became victors. He then joins the rebellion forces of the fallen District 13 and they eventually put an end to The Hunger Games for good.
It is obvious that anyone with half a heart and mind would want to stop the “send your kids to slaughter” reality television show, especially if you were once in it. But Haymitch’s story runs so much deeper than the obvious.
The story follows a 16-year-old Haymitch during his time as a tribute in the second Quarter Quell games. The anniversary “spin” is that there are double the tributes from each district being thrown into the flowery, poison-ridden arena to fight to the death.
Haymitch’s story highlights the use of media for propaganda. With future rebellion ally Plutarch Heavensbee, Frankenstein-ing every mishap from the Capitol and twisting narratives to damn or protect whomever President Snow chooses. It shines a light on the background workings of how stories can be manipulated for an agenda, a lesson many of us need to heed now more than ever in the face of AI and mass misinformation.
Stripping away the postmodern grays and concrete of Katniss’s games, Haymitch’s trip to the Capitol is colorful and psychedelic, reminiscent of the 60s. The flowery, mid-century modern setting contrasts with the cruelty in an even more eerie way. What looks like a cozy living room is actually a surveilled terror chamber; what looks like a beautiful butterfly is actually a taser. The false safety added to the “don’t believe everything you see” narrative in a terrifyingly satisfying way.
The story introduces a new batch of characters to love and loathe, including fellow District 12 tribute Maysilee Donner, played by Mckenna Grace, and Haymitch’s “darling” Lenore Dove, portrayed by Whitney Peak. It also has the treat of Kieran Culkin’s Ceaser Flickerman. Honestly, his version wasn’t even close to Stanley Tucci’s portrayal and is really just Kieran Culkin in a wig. He was funny enough that I forgave the inconsistency.
Woody Harrelson is a tough act to follow, especially when he played the fan-favorite Haymitch as spectacularly as he did, but newcomer Joseph Zada genuinely blew me away.
Though the original books pointed to a tragic backstory for Abernathy, we didn’t get the gruesome details until Sunrise on the Reaping. And they were, in fact, gruesome. Zada led the audience through numerous heart-wrenching and painful scenes, and you could feel the energy in the room sink and rise with his.
Though we already know the sole survivor, the story still douses us in false hopes. One of the many beauties of this addition to The Hunger Games is that it shows that freedom and liberation don’t happen overnight. And, more importantly, they don’t come without major pushback from the iron fist of fascist regimes. Haymitch’s story makes way for Katniss’s and paints a much more realistic picture of her rebellion’s eventual victory.
There were many moments that stuck out to me, but the showstopper was one that genuinely made me feel the same as when Katniss was airlifted out of the Quarter Quell. You’ll know it when you see it.
The Hunger Games truly understands what it takes to make a great book-to-movie adaptation. This story sticks to the book religiously, even more so than the original trilogy. Like how the movies completely disregarded that Peeta actually lost his leg in the arena during the first book. [I’m still bitter about it, if you can’t tell.]
It is safe to say that the winning streak Suzanne Collins is on has not faltered or budged in the slightest. Director Francis Lawrence and writers Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie took excellent care of Collins’ characters and creation.
Despite my qualms about revisiting certain stories and worlds, this did not feel like beating a dead horse. It limited the nostalgia and offered us a fresh, arguably needed, perspective on the overall story of Panem.
If anyone needs me, I will be rewatching all of the movies and going back to the theatres on Friday to watch this one again when I’m done. It’s that serious, folks.



