Who would have guessed that 31 years after M*A*S*H, the film that made Robert Altman’s reputation, he would still be turning out movies as good as his latest release, Gosford Park? Full of the director’s usual energy, powered by the sense of controlled chaos that marks all of his ensemble films, Gosford Park also finds the quintessentially American director completely at home in the alien milieu of 1932 England.
In form, Gosford Park exists in the tradition of innumerable old movies (including many adapted from Agatha Christie novels) in which a group of people, all with their own agendas, are thrown together in an isolated country house; a murder occurs, and a savvy detective must figure out who among the several guests with strong motives actually committed the crime. As usual, Altman is less concerned with crafting a perfect example of the genre as he is with examining the genre itself. Neil Simon already did the ultimate parody of this stuff in the 1976 Murder by Death (in which Maggie Smith, one of the stars of Gosford Park, also appears); Altman’s approach is not so much a satire as a reimagining of the genre’s conventions, with the class elements emphasized.
Like M*A*S*H, Nashville, Short Cuts and numerous other Altman projects, Gosford Park drops the viewer into a complex, frantic situation with no clear-cut protagonist to cling to. The closest the film comes to a central character is Mary Maceachran (Kelly Macdonald), a demure young maid accompanying her aged employer, the snobbish Lady Trentham (Smith), for a weekend party at the summer house of crusty Sir William McCordle (Michael Gambon), whose coldhearted wife, Sylvia (Kristin Scott Thomas), is Lady Trentham’s niece.
Also in attendance are Sylvia’s two sisters (Geraldine Somerville and Natasha Wightman) and their husbands (Charles Dance and Tom Hollander). In addition, there is the McCordle daughter (Camilla Rutherford); Ivor Novello (Jeremy Northam), the real-life British songwriter and matinee idol whose persona Altman and screenwriter Julian Fellowes have borrowed for the film; and his guest, a Hollywood producer (Bob Balaban, who also coproduced Gosford Park) doing background research for the upcoming Charlie Chan in London.
If this seems intimidatingly complicated, be assured that you haven’t heard the half of it. There are four more guests, whose relationships to the others continue to baffle me (after two viewings of the movie). Indeed, two of them seem so tangential to everything in the film that one can only wonder if they are remnants of a subplot that was excised in the final cut. And we haven’t even gotten to the servants yet, who are the real heart of the story.
What the servants in this world lack in money and power, they compensate for with ritual and knowledge. That is, while they know everything that’s going on in both their realm and the upstairs world of their wealthy and/or titled employers, the latter know very little about what goes on downstairs. Altman is careful to show us how the downstairs people are omnipresent, even as they strive to self-effacingly blend in with the woodwork. On one hand, it is their pleasure and validation to serve; on the other, they are completely aware of their bosses’ utter helplessness without them.
Mary, new to service, functions much of the time as our surrogate, as the house staff — butler (Alan Bates), housekeeper (Helen Mirren), cook (Eileen Atkins, cocreator of Upstairs Downstairs, to which the film clearly owes a debt), footmen (Richard E. Grant and Jeremy Swift) and head housemaid (Emily Watson) — explain to her the insane rules mandated by tradition. They inform her that visiting servants will be addressed only by the names of their employers, effectively stripping them of any other identity; likewise, each will have his or her seat at dinner determined by the employer’s rank.
This may sound like P.G. Wodehouse-land: Jeeves, who took the notion of valet’s duty into the realm of genius, would have been at home here. But, aside from Jeeves, Wodehouse was less interested in the community of servants; nor would he ever have ventured anywhere near Gosford Park‘s concern with sexual matters, particularly the “class miscegenation” between the upstairs and downstairs folk.
If there is a problem with Gosford Park, it’s that Altman seems so enthralled with the interplay of the characters that he’s reluctant to put much energy into the mystery itself. The murder doesn’t occur until past the midway point. And the “brilliant” inspector (Stephen Fry) is so totally imbecilic, so broadly portrayed, he seems to have wandered in from a different film altogether — possibly Murder by Death. Still, there is a payoff to the murder, one inextricably integrated with all the class interactions the movie has set up so carefully.
Altman characteristically has his cameramen prowl around a set in which numerous events are unfolding simultaneously; he often seems to concentrate on the most trivial (if absorbing) activities, while the important stuff is going on in the background or solely on the soundtrack. It’s a canny technique, particularly for a mystery: We never know whether the highlighting of certain things is important or not. When the camera adopts such an indiscriminate eye, clues can be dropped in without being obvious.
Altman’s technique also allows his huge cast to act up a storm, in the best sense. Gosford Park has roughly half of the best actors in England in it; in addition to those mentioned above, it also features Derek Jacobi, James Wilby and Clive Owen. (And American heartthrob Ryan Phillippe is here, too, and perfect for his role.) Much of the beauty of what the actors provide is not apparent on a single viewing; the second time around, armed with foreknowledge of who these people are and what is going to happen, one can interpret numerous little expressions and reactions that were seemingly meaningless the first time.
It really is amazing that Altman has endured this long, through all his career ups and downs. He is 76 now, and I can’t think of another American director who has still turned out first-rate work at that age. (Hitchcock was 72 when he made Frenzy; Cukor, 65 for My Fair Lady; Wilder, 72 for Fedora, which was first-rate for only part of its length; none of the three was American-born.) Altman’s last effort, 2000’s Dr. T and the Women, was one of his most critically reviled films ever — down there with his last sally into Europe, 1994’s fashion-world spoof Ready to Wear. Gosford Park should do much to salvage his reputation.